Take what I’ve posted here with a grain of salt: it’s June 2009, and Hyperspaces has been in beta for close to 6 months. Life tends to happen, and I’m sure my users are happier that I chose to give them something to play with. I’ve learnt a lot about the process though, which I’ll blog about at some point.
With the Hyperspaces public beta coming quite soon, I’ve been thinking about how to release beta software, and when it’s appropriate to do so.
My previous piece of software - VirtueDesktops - had eternal beta syndrome (EBS). Hell, while I was running the project I’m not even sure I’d have called it a beta knowing what I do now. This was a huge fucking mistake. And it showed. Users got awfully upset, and the only reason I got away with it was because I didn’t charge anything for the software.
How often do you download a great new piece of software that’s in beta, and then spend the next 6 months waiting for it to become stable enough for daily use? Seriously, if you couldn’t realistically release a bug-free version of your software within 4 weeks of putting out your public beta - hold off and get your software to a point where you can!
I believe the most important thing I have as a developer is my reputation. Skills, languages and patterns can be learnt - reputation is something that has to be earned, and is really hard to rebuild if you damage it. In my experience buggy releases or a constantly “in-beta” product are two of the fastest ways to cripple your reputation.
This applies regardless of the release status of your application - if something goes wrong, the user will only let you know if:
I generally believe in collecting as much information as possible and automatically posting this back to your servers - this way, you don’t need to ask the user to root about in their Library folder. If you’re going to do this, make sure you let the user know exactly what’s happening!. When I was coding VirtueDesktops, I used Unsanity’s Smart Crash Reporter - and was quite happy with it. I’m still not sure what I’ll use for Hyperspaces - APE is out for Leopard now, but it’s not out of beta yet.
Don’t release your software before it’s ready, and make sure it’s easy to report errors when they happen.